I'm low-key furious. A friend just took the immensely brave step of telling her GP she thinks she is trans and wants to go on hormones, and he (a cis, gay man) tried to "supportively" convince her that she wasn't really trans, because he "has trans friends" and knows that if she was really a woman "she would know".
Fuck. That. Shithead.
1/
As a trans person, I'm bitterly familiar with the phenomenon where any misdeed committed by any other person who happens to be trans— no matter how far removed they are from me by any other measure— will be used to cast aspersions on my own morality and trustworthiness, because we "share an ideology".
This is a post about Berlin.
I identify as a #plural system— to oversimplify, I feel that there is not so much a single cohesive "me" as a, well, plurality of them.
With careful introspection I can notice myself switching between which version of me is "fronting", or observe myself to be operating in a more "blended" mode.
1/
I was watching a video of trans experiences, which included this lovely older trans woman. And everything she said was very resonant, except for one thing: she said that in her experience the sex that trans women have after vaginoplasty is typically disappointing, brings little pleasure, and they often give up on it after a while.
This, to be frank, is not the experience I'm familiar with, within my own social group. And I wondered at first if this implied that vaginoplasty techniques had improved so rapidly in the last couple of decades.
But then as she spoke more about her dating life, I realised something else: she seemed to have gone straight from having sex with cis women, to having sex with cis men. Which was probably a common life arc in her own social group.
And I don't want to be so crass as to say "girl, that's your problem right there", but... 😬
I regard with growing alarm the idea of "trauma dumping" as a supposed negative— that talking frankly about your troubles is variously unusual, rude, harmful, or even something to be punished. It seems to be verging even on an idea that trauma is somehow something which is infectious, spread by talking about. 1/
I think I've finally put my finger on another "Geek Social Fallacy".
But first, if you're not familiar with the original, go and check it out
https://plausiblydeniable.com/five-geek-social-fallacies/
(I know "geek" is a very dated descriptor, but the same observations continue to hold for a lot of communities, especially queer and/or neurodiverse ones). 1/
@grumpygamer@mastodon.gamedev.place
"What the fuck did you do to my fence? I'm not paying you for this!"
"Looks fine to me."
"All the cuts are splintered and jaggy! It's a health hazard."
"Oh yeah, I didn't do that."
"What? Who did?"
"The chainsaw."
"The... Huh?"
"Yeah I'm a firm believer in automated tooling. Instead of spending time manually cutting and smoothing everything, I just trust the machine to do it all for me. It's so much faster."
"I paid you expecting a certain level of quality to your work."
"You can't blame me for poor workmanship. My hands never touched your fence. Take it up with the chainsaw if you have a problem with it."
@thatfrisiangirlish@blahaj.zone I think even in my angry atheist stage I always saw organised religion as a vector for injustice, and not the actual form of it.
I remember arguing with other atheists that "yeah, but, plenty of horrible things have been done by secular governments too, even ones that are anti-religious", and the sheer mental gymnastics that prompted in response. Everything could be traced back to religion, I was told, and if we got rid of that, all injustice would somehow evaporate.
That's an unfounded belief that struck me as ironically cultlike.
@faithisleaping@anarres.family came here to say, well, basically exactly what you did.
I feel I had some privileges that the cis women around me didn't, in certain situations. They also had privileges that I, a closeted trans woman, didn't.
Similarly, since coming out and transitioning I've noticed a complex shift of privileges. On the whole tho I feel that the primary privilege I gained— of living as my authentic self— is more fundamental and valuable to me than all the ones I've lost by moving thru life as a woman.
@revoluciana@chaosfem.tw
@sinituulia yes! They are all so different.
Zeph likes to come up near to where I am and start purring.
This is not a request for stroking— he's quite touch-averse— he just likes to body double.
@anotherdream
@futzle@old.mermaid.town I mute the merely tiresome, and block the downright obnoxious.
So often I've seen reply guys escalate their behaviour in later comment threads and become full-blown trolls with terrible opinions. It really makes sense to curate them out of my Fedi experience before that point.
@Tooden@aus.social since Pratchett has already been shown some love in this thread I'll quote his idea that "treating people as things" is the root cause.
Patriarchy— as the objectification of women— is perhaps the oldest instance of this, but see also colonialism, capitalism, feudalism...
@thatfrisiangirlish@blahaj.zone
@thatfrisiangirlish@blahaj.zone this is such a good take, and something I've been grappling with in the past year or so as I embrace witchiness. I know my beliefs in this regard are unfounded, a matter of faith. Almost the point of it all is to sit with uncertainty, to be comfortable with not knowing.
Peace necessitates being able to be in relation to others who might have wildly different philosophies, and to do that I think it's necessarily to have at least an inking of the contingent nature of our own belief system.
@JoscelynTransient@chaosfem.tw damn good thing for hitmen to know, on reflection. If I was a crime lord (Crime Lady?) I'd make my henches at least attend a course.
@NanoRaptor@bitbang.social it's not enough to just read about prehistory, we have to be there, experience it with all our senses.
Yes, all our senses, did I stutter?
@mjd@mathstodon.xyz
Typically the ex-Christian atheist would say "there's no such thing as a 'Christian' or 'Jewish' atheist, as atheism precludes religion", but that understanding is based specifically in Christian doctrine.
For this reason "Christian atheist" is indeed very much a contradiction in terms under most understandings*, whereas "Jewish atheist" definitely isn't.
@babble_endanger@freeradical.zone do you mean by that that it evolves into a game of literal points-scoring, with the main motivation being "number go up"?
@Oggie yep. I went thru an obnoxious phase, but what I realise now is that I was grieving. I'd lost a personally meaningful relationship with a father figure (in God), and I was angry that I had been given that only for it to be taken away.
And yeah, this was around about 20 years old. I was young, I'd been thrown out into the world to try to figure out where I fit, I was closeted to myself and the world, and I was struggling. I have compassion for the self I was back then.
And then as I found happiness and security in life, I grew out of this phase. I learnt to find confidence in not knowing everything, to sit with the fundamental uncertainty of being.
@inthehands
Hi @rebeccawatson , thanks for this. I was wondering whether there should be a link at this point in the transcript?
I won’t go more into that but if you’re interested, check out this video I made in 2022 on this topic, largely inspired by my having read Siddhartha and developing a finer understanding of the interconnectedness of all things in our Universe
...as I am indeed interested. 🙂
@Tooden@aus.social you're right that I haven't explicitly explored that part. But I've said I want to draw a line under this, and you've been respectful of that on your part, so I'll stick to my guns 😅
Have a good day!